Whether you prefer thin-crust or deep-dish, there’s no denying that a slice of cheesy, goodness from My Pizza can satisfy your hunger.
We have an unparalleled mix of hot, hot yummy mozzarella and the delicious marinara to invoke the greatest of flavors once you opt to enjoy it.
Top Ten Winner
Staten Island Advance
Best Specialty Pie
October 2024
Home made deep fried crispy potato croquettes served with marinara sauce
Bread roll with fried chicken, marinara sauce, garlic, cheese & red peppers
Bread roll with grilled chicken, marinara sauce, garlic, cheese & red peppers
Veggi burger with lettuce, tomato, onion on a bun with fries & tahini sauce on the side
Gyro chicken with lettuce, tomato, onion on a pita bread with fries & tzatziki sauce
Gyro lamb with lettuce, tomato, onion on a pita bread with fries & tzatziki sauce
Fried chicken with romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing & melted parmigiano cheese
Grilled chicken with romaine lettuce, Caesar dressing & melted parmigiano cheese
Sauté chicken cubes in homemade buffalo sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese
Egg battered chicken cubes in a lemon sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese
Sauté chicken & mushroom in marsala sauce topped with mozzarella cheese
Thinly sliced beef with onions, peppers topped with melted American cheese
Breaded jumbo fried shrimp in marinara sauce topped with mozzarella cheese
Breaded & seasoned chicken with marinara sauce topped with parmigiana
Sauté chicken in homemade buffalo sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese
Egg battered chicken in a lemon sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese
Golden fried eggplant with marinara sauc topped with melted mozzarella cheese
Thinly sliced beef strips grilled with onions topped with American cheese
Thinly sliced beef strips grilled with onions, mushrooms & peppers topped with American cheese
Fried jumbo shrimps (4) with marinara sauce topped with melted mozzarella cheese
Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, peppers, olives & onions w/ small 1 Chicken Piece & large 2 pieces
Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, peppers, olives & onions w/ small 1 Chicken Piece & large 2 pieces
Buffalo style chicken cubes with lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, peppers, olives & onions
Romaine lettuce, croutons topped with freshly graded parmigiana cheese w/ small 1 Chicken Piece & large 2 pieces
Romaine lettuce, croutons topped with freshly graded parmigiana cheese w/ small 1 Chicken Piece & large 2 pieces
Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, peppers, olives, onions topped with jumbo shrimps (6)
Iceberg lettuce, tomato, cucumbers, peppers, olives, onions topped with jumbo shrimps (6)
Shredded chicken cooked in onion, celery, carrots with seasoning & noodles
Stuffed shells with ricotta cheese cooked in marinara sauce & topped with mozzarella cheese
Rolls filled with ricotta cheese baked in marinara sauce & topped with mozzarella cheese
Fresh oven-baked knots drizzled with butter, topped with parmesean cheese and spices
Fresh oven-baked bread with garlic, butter & spices, served with marinara sauce
Home-made deep-fried crispy croquettes made with potato and served with marinara sauce
Deep fried chicken wings served with blue cheese/rnch dressing and celery stiks with hot sauce on the side
Deep fried chicken wings served with blue cheese/rnch dressing and celery stiks with hot sauce on the side
Iceberg lettuce, cherry tomatoes, cucumbers, bell peppers, green olives, onions
Sliced fresh mozzarella and sliced tomatos sprinkled with basil drizzled with olive oil
Rolls filled with ricotta cheese baked in marinara sauce & topped with mozzerella cheese
Stuffed shells with ricotta cheese cooked in marinara sauce & topped with mozzerella cheese
Fried eggplant rolled with ricotta & fresh mozzarella cheese with choice pasta of in marinara sauce
Chicken with choice of pasta in lemon butter sauce/ Chicken with choice of pasta in mushroom marsala sauce
Fried chicken rolled with ricotta & fresh mozzarella cheese in marinara sauce with choice of pasta
Fried Chicken with pasta in housemade vodka sauce with mozzerella cheese
Breaded veal cutlet served with choice of pasta in marinara sauce topped with mozzerella cheese
Breaded veal cutlet cooked in lemon butter sauce and served with choice of pasta
Call now at (718) 720-7777 and place your order for pickup or delivery at your doorstep.
The best pizza ever! We always stop here when we come through Staten Island. The buffalo chicken slice is my favorite. My husband loves the spinach chicken alfredo slice.
I walked in as they were closing. They are nice people working there. I ordered the chicken alfredo slice and it was yummy! Hot and delicious! The crust was crunchy and buttery. The dough it self was soft like bread. Highly recommend
The food was so delicious. I ordered pizza and then some chicken dinners for my family. When we passed by again everyone wanted to stop and get lunch. I brought one Alfredo pie to bring to our hotel.
This place has good food for a good price. Comparable to brooklyn pizza. Fourth time trying today with no complaints so far.
Satisfy your cravings with our savory crust, handcrafted marinara sauce, and tantalizing toppings. My Pizza delivers delicious satisfaction.
Sign up for our newsletter & get 10% off bill offers and invites!
Slices 
Cheese Pie 
Calzones & Rolls 
Appetizers & Sides 
Wings Planet 
Burger, Gyro & Wraps 
Foot Long Heros 
Salads & Soups 
Entrees 
Pasta & Baked Pasta 
Beverages / Sodas 
Dessert & Extras 
Appetizers 
Salad 
Vegetable 
Pasta 
Entree 
Chicken 
Shrimp 
Veal